Review: A Beautiful Noise (Sydney Lyric Theatre)

Venue: Sydney Lyric Theatre (Sydney NSW), Nov 14, 2026 – Feb 14, 2027
Book: Anthony McCarten
Music and Lyrics: Neil Diamond
Director: Michael Mayer
Cast: Terence Crawford, Hannah Fredericksen, Paul Hanlon, Mark Owen-Taylor, Ashleigh Rubenach, Monica Sayers, Will Swenson, Alana Tranter, Tim Wright
Images by Jeff Busby

Theatre review
Neil Diamond’s extraordinary career in the music industry is beyond dispute, but A Beautiful Noise, the musical drawn from his songs and life story, offers little indication of a comparably compelling life. Nor does the catalogue consistently justify its revival. However deeply these songs once resonated with listeners, much of the repertoire arguably lacks the enduring appeal required to transcend its original era. The 2022 musical, featuring a book by Anthony McCarten, consequently feels tired and banal for substantial stretches of its duration.

Performer Will Swenson nevertheless deserves credit for finding unexpected vulnerability in a figure associated with an assertively masculine persona. His vocal impersonation supplies ample nostalgic pleasure during the musical numbers, although the same commitment to mimicry becomes grating in scenes depicting Diamond away from the microphone. Terence Crawford plays the singer in his eighties, appearing less frequently but benefiting from material that, however clichéd, offers greater dramatic substance. Crawford lends the production a persuasive humanity, though its arrival is too belated to provide the emotional resonance so conspicuously absent elsewhere.

As biographical jukebox musicals evolve from a fashionable trend into an established theatrical convention, their frequently limited creativity invites scrutiny. At their least imaginative, these productions amount to little more than the repackaging of familiar catalogues, finding new ways to sell audiences what they already know. Artistically accomplished examples have demonstrated the form’s potential, but works such as A Beautiful Noise suggest an increasing willingness to treat familiarity as a substitute for invention. Nostalgia may be a dependable commercial proposition; it is considerably less reliable as an artistic one.

www.theneildiamondmusical.com.au