
Venue: Hayes Theatre Co (Potts Point NSW), Nov 13 – Dec 19, 2026
Book: Jacob Parker and Miranda Middleton
Music and Lyrics: Alec Steedman
Director: Richard Carroll
Cast: Natalie Abbott, Marty Alix, Victoria Falconer, Jack Green, Tana Laga’aia, Billie Palin, Shannen Alyce Quan
Images by John McRae
Theatre review
Taken under the wing of seasoned pirate Silver, Jim sets sail in pursuit of adventure and glory, unaware that they are both propelled by unfinished business. Their shared experience of abandonment lends a further affinity to the relationship, establishing an emotional foundation for Silver Tongue. The book by Jacob Parker and Miranda Middleton offers a thoughtful premise, but devotes so much energy to comedy that the storytelling suffers. Without a sufficiently robust narrative to draw us in, we remain at a distance, watching events unfold without becoming particularly invested in their outcome. The abundance of jokes, too many of them lacklustre, does little to compensate.
Alec Steedman’s songs are considerably more rewarding, their melodic appeal and rousing spirit earning the production a measure of goodwill. Director Richard Carroll cannot make every punchline land, but the quirky sensibility he brings to proceedings has a warmth that proves engaging. His staging also possesses an unmistakable polish, sustaining our attention even when the material falters. Hailley Hunt’s set is especially appealing, bringing an unexpected sumptuousness to the familiar rustic textures of pirate adventures. Ryan McDonald’s lighting is similarly rich, creating imagery that is both evocative and visually satisfying.
A tireless cast approaches the material with an admirable determination to make it work. As Silver, Billie Palin is wonderfully dynamic, embodying the swagger and charisma of the swashbuckling pirate with effortless conviction. Her performance makes the character’s gender feel entirely unremarkable, allowing authority, daring and theatrical presence to define the role. Marty Alix, meanwhile, brings a naturalism to Jim that can seem overly subdued amid the flamboyance surrounding them, leaving the character at risk of receding from the action.
Silver Tongue is driven above all by a desire to entertain. Placing a woman at the centre of a pirate adventure carries a subversive charge, but the musical makes no great claim to political intervention. We may ask our artists to have something to say, yet the ability to give an audience a good time is no lesser ambition. The production does not consistently fulfil that promise, but its exuberance and generosity remain palpable, even when the treasure proves elusive.




