Venue: Hayes Theatre Co (Potts Point NSW), Jun 23 – Jul 23, 2023
Music: Cy Coleman
Lyrics: David Zippel
Book: Larry Gelbart
Director: Sam Hooper
Cast: Madeleine Betts, Doron Chester, Chantel Cofie, Sian Crowe, Paul Hanlon, Glenn Hill, Noah Janssen, Katelin Koprivec, Penny McNamee, Mia Morrissey, Conor Neylon, Shannen Alyce Quan, Ethan Rutledge, Marcus Rivera, Aaron Tsindos, Jessica White
Images by Grant Leslie
Theatre review
It is the 1940s and Stine is adapting his award-winning novel into a screenplay for Hollywood. Transitioning from one art form to another proves challenging, as he tries to preserve artistic integrity, in what quickly proves to be little more than a commercial venture. In the 1989 musical City of Angels, we see both Stine’s reality as well as a manifestation of his film noir creation, involving a private detective Stone and the various temptresses within his orbit. Despite its highly convoluted plot structure, the payoff is ultimately underwhelming, offering a narrative that feels much too predictable. Furthermore its humour seems not to have stood the test of time, although it must be said that music composition is its silver lining, with every song proving to be masterfully composed, by the legendary Cy Coleman.
The 3-hour production is valiantly revived by director Sam Hooper, who although demonstrates passionate verve, lacks inventiveness and an eye for detail. City of Angels not only requires great ambition, it demands a meticulousness and sophistication that few are able to muster. There is an evident lack of polish in the set design by Simon Greer, which can be blamed for the many clumsy, and noisy, scene changes. Lights by James Wallis attempt to create a sense of delineation between real and reel, but is in general too muted and lifeless. Costume designs by Esther Zhong are more accomplished, able to instinctively convey personality types of the many characters we encounter.
Music direction by Abi McCunn and Damon Wade, is the unequivocal highlight, greatly evocative of the big band era, with just seven musicians delivering all that is necessary to take us back in time, sonically at least. Singing is also of a high standard, with Glenn Hill and Aaron Tsindos (as Stine and Stone respectively), leading a cast that is never short of dedication and commitment. More memorable performances include Mia Morrissey playing dual roles of Gabby and Bobbi, introducing sensuality along with authenticity, to a production that tries to negotiate the outmoded and problematic portrayals of womanhood. Marcus Rivera is unforgettable in the number “All You Have to Do Is Wait” as Muñoz, full of intensity and unapologetic in a rare singular moment of candour, that feels suddenly resonant.
In 2023 it is perhaps no longer a surprise, that to make money, a portion of a person’s soul has to be sold, along with whatever labour is entailed in the transactive process. Just several decades ago, it had felt poignant to see an artist losing their way, when trying to exploit the big-money world of commercialised entertainment. Today at a time of late capitalism, idealism for artists seems a distant memory, yet we persist in searching for something of greater value, than what can be commodified. Within that spirit, we understand that money can never completely encompass what we do, that it is always the immaterial that represents our true purpose, even as we learn to accept that that which is material, should no longer be seen only as the evil adversary.
Suzy Goes See 